Smith Street Pizza
Claim this businessAbout
Low-key pie spot specializing in crispy-crust NY-style pizza slices with varying toppings.
Services
Reviews (249)
Brian Raymanfrom Google
Maybe the best pizza in Carol Gardens and that’s saying a lot if you know Pizza. I love the margarita slice, the eggplant slice and the vodka slice — you can’t go wrong and not necessarily in that order. They may not know garlic knots but that’s OK, I don’t go there for the knots. Go get a slice.
Matthew Chamofffrom Google
Get in. Grab your slices. Get out. Ear there. Take them to go. So many NY Slice options around but this one is the real deal. I think I've been here 300 times. I come here at least twice per week. Crust is good. Pie is a always fresh unlike other hyped up places on the street. Keep up the good work.
dan73nyc Alvaradofrom Google
The cleanest Pizzaria that I've ever been! Quality of the dough is superb! My son and I don't understand why there's no line!!! It blows L"Industria Pizza away to the Moon!
Jimmy Liangfrom Google
Happened upon this pizza joint just because we were in the area this past summer and payed another visit this week. Just as good as I remembered—crust was crispy, cheese was gooey, toppings were generous and delicious! I personally love their mushroom slice, but the jalapeño chicken slice is 🔥too (in both sense of the word)! Before this place becomes too popular to sit for a slice at 5pm on a Friday, this spot is going up there for the best slices in BK awards. Try it, you’ll know what I mean!
Tony Del Pinofrom Google
As I continue my unofficial Pizza Tour of NYC, I came upon Smith Street Pizza in Cobble Hill. There are some other main stays in the neighborhood but I wanted to give this spot a go. I usually opt for a Pepperoni slice as a barometer, but I also was craving a specialty slice with more substance. I decided to go with the Buffalo Chicken slice. Must say it was one of the better ones I have had. Plentiful amount of chicken. Great balance between Buffalo sauce and blue cheese sauce. The chicken was juicy and the crust itself was crispy with a bit of chew. A well executed slice! Would definitely try again when I'm back in Cobble Hill