About
Old-school, wood-lined venue with red booths for slices with creative toppings & Sicilian pies.
Services
Reviews (1423)
Lionel Sanabriafrom Google
The square pies here are hands down some of the best square pizzas I’ve ever had. The dough is nice and fluffy, the crust has a great texture, and overall it’s just an out-of-this-world pie. Definitely the reason to come here. The pepperoni sticks are decent too. Service is regular, nothing bad, nothing over the top. The only downside is the seating inside is pretty small. If you’re coming with 4 or more people, it can feel cramped trying to sit down and eat, especially if you order full pies for the table. But overall, the square pie alone is a knockout and easily the highlight of the place.
Ramiz Soskicfrom Google
Pizza Wagon in Brooklyn is an absolute hidden gem! 🍕⭐️ The pizza was incredibly fresh, flavorful, and honestly one of the best we’ve had in New York. You can really taste the quality of the ingredients and the passion that goes into every slice. Perfect crust, amazing sauce, and great portions — simply delicious! The atmosphere was relaxed and authentic, exactly what you hope for when looking for a real Brooklyn pizza spot. The staff was super friendly, welcoming, and made us feel right at home from the moment we walked in. If you’re in Brooklyn and craving amazing pizza, Pizza Wagon is definitely a must-visit. We were more than satisfied and will absolutely come back next time we’re in NYC! Highly recommended! 🔥🍕
Jason Escobarfrom Google
The best. Sicilian pizza in New York City. I’d loved it. I had two slices. I wish I could eat more.
L (Tiff)from Google
Shout-out to Pizza Wagon! I stopped by today to order pizza and didn’t realize they only accept cash. After ordering, I noticed I hadn’t brought my wallet, but the employee was incredibly kind and generous and told me it was okay, I could pay next time. Such a sweet and trustworthy gesture that really made my day. Just a heads-up to bring cash when you visit! I’ll definitely be back again for another visit (and to return the favor). Highly recommend!
J B Cfrom Google
I decided to cut through Bay Ridge on my way home Saturday when I drove past Pizza Wagon. I hadn’t had pizza in a while so I decided to give it a shot, since pizza is usually quick & inexpensive. I had a chicken roll which was a bit small but tasty. Though it may have been a bit smaller than I’m used to it was also cost a little less so I’d call it even. I also had a white slice of pizza which was crispy & delicious. The place is so small they don’t have a visible restroom. (In NY if a restaurant has less then a certain amount of seating they’re not required to have a restroom for customers…unless a law changed I’m unaware of) It seemed like most of their business was take out that day. They had some memorabilia decorating the walls & awards. If you’re in the area check it out.